True story:
I saw this book everywhere. The Girl with a Dragon Tattoo. It was piled up at Costco, a movie had come out, and it looked like everyone was reading it. So I checked it out, and took it home. My 8th grade daughter saw me reading it one winter's day, and said, "Oh, that's what Kaitlyn is reading. Can I read it when you're done?" I gave her my standard, "We'll see."
I could not finish that book. The horrible, graphic, depictions of sexual violence on women make me feel sick to this day. Like the opening scenes in "Leaving Las Vegas," there are some images that I cannot get out of my head, that terrify me in the dark of sleepless nights. Why our culture embraces tales of depravity, I'll never understand. But letting 13 or 14 year old be exposed to such is criminal.
Adult books are not for kids. Even adults shouldn't be reading most of them.
Now for the boring stuff about finding age appropriate reading material for your children.
Our local library uses the Dewey Decimal System, as do most public libraries. Like it or not, the DDS leaves a lot of ambiguity with the generic "F" for Fiction. In Youth Services, the vague delineations are furthered with "JF" for Juvenile Fiction and "YF" for Young Adult Fiction. The hard-working people who decide whether a book is J or Y, most likely use reading level, and in special cases, content. Juvenile fiction is generally for elementary school children, up to about 6th grade. Young Adult is then for the middle school kids, 7th and 8th grades. Some libraries have a High School section, which includes adult books about teenagers, or content judged inappropriate for children.
There is a lot of crossover between J and Y books, and each library makes it's own calls. You may find the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series in either category, depending on which library you go to. In Juvenile books, you can find all the silly, gross, My Butt from Mars type books. But, (no pun intended) you can also find nearly every children's classic and loads of good stories that will interest readers of any age. In Young Adult, you can find most of the paranormal (Cirque du Freak, Twilight, etc.), romances (from Princess Diaries to Anne of Avonlea), and weightier themes such as crime, death of a loved one, homelessness, etc.
Young Adult books are some of the greatest books I've ever read. And also some of the worst. I believe that writing for this age group is often more demanding than writing for children or adults. I also realize that the popularity machine that catapults books into a frenzied craze begins with young adults. So, when reading YA, I am always cautious, and often amazed with what I find.
Here is a list of several YA books that I read, enjoyed, and consider appropriate for my teen son and daughter.
The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman
Schooled by Gordon Korman
The Dangerous Days of Daniel X by James Patterson
Trouble by Gary D. Schmidt
Peak by Roland Smith
When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead
Leviathan by Scot Westerfeld
Vampire Rising by Jason Henderson
Stormbreaker by Anthony Horowitz
Woods Runner by Gary Paulsen
Notes from the Midnight Driver by Jordan Sonnenblick
Little Blog on the Prairie by Cathleen Davitt Bell
Princess of the Midnight Ball by Jessica Day George
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Thursday, July 21, 2011
Mamas, Don't Let Your Babies Grow Up to Read "The Girl with a Dragon Tattoo"
True story:
I saw this book everywhere. The Girl with a Dragon Tattoo. It was piled up at Costco, a movie had come out, and it looked like everyone was reading it. So I checked it out, and took it home. My 8th grade daughter saw me reading it one winter's day, and said, "Oh, that's what Kaitlyn is reading. Can I read it when you're done?" I gave her my standard, "We'll see."
I could not finish that book. The horrible, graphic, depictions of sexual violence on women make me feel sick to this day. Like the opening scenes in "Leaving Las Vegas," there are some images that I cannot get out of my head, that terrify me in the dark of sleepless nights. Why our culture embraces tales of depravity, I'll never understand. But letting 13 or 14 year old be exposed to such is criminal.
Adult books are not for kids. Even adults shouldn't be reading most of them.
Now for the boring stuff about finding age appropriate reading material for your children.
Our local library uses the Dewey Decimal System, as do most public libraries. Like it or not, the DDS leaves a lot of ambiguity with the generic "F" for Fiction. In Youth Services, the vague delineations are furthered with "JF" for Juvenile Fiction and "YF" for Young Adult Fiction. The hard-working people who decide whether a book is J or Y, most likely use reading level, and in special cases, content. Juvenile fiction is generally for elementary school children, up to about 6th grade. Young Adult is then for the middle school kids, 7th and 8th grades. Some libraries have a High School section, which includes adult books about teenagers, or content judged inappropriate for children.
There is a lot of crossover between J and Y books, and each library makes it's own calls. You may find the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series in either category, depending on which library you go to. In Juvenile books, you can find all the silly, gross, My Butt from Mars type books. But, (no pun intended) you can also find nearly every children's classic and loads of good stories that will interest readers of any age. In Young Adult, you can find most of the paranormal (Cirque du Freak, Twilight, etc.), romances (from Princess Diaries to Anne of Avonlea), and weightier themes such as crime, death of a loved one, homelessness, etc.
Young Adult books are some of the greatest books I've ever read. And also some of the worst. I believe that writing for this age group is often more demanding than writing for children or adults. I also realize that the popularity machine that catapults books into a frenzied craze begins with young adults. So, when reading YA, I am always cautious, and often amazed with what I find.
Here is a list of several YA books that I read, enjoyed, and consider appropriate for my teen son and daughter.
The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman
Schooled by Gordon Korman
The Dangerous Days of Daniel X by James Patterson
Trouble by Gary D. Schmidt
Peak by Roland Smith
When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead
Leviathan by Scot Westerfeld
Vampire Rising by Jason Henderson
Stormbreaker by Anthony Horowitz
Woods Runner by Gary Paulsen
Notes from the Midnight Driver by Jordan Sonnenblick
Little Blog on the Prairie by Cathleen Davitt Bell
Princess of the Midnight Ball by Jessica Day George
I saw this book everywhere. The Girl with a Dragon Tattoo. It was piled up at Costco, a movie had come out, and it looked like everyone was reading it. So I checked it out, and took it home. My 8th grade daughter saw me reading it one winter's day, and said, "Oh, that's what Kaitlyn is reading. Can I read it when you're done?" I gave her my standard, "We'll see."
I could not finish that book. The horrible, graphic, depictions of sexual violence on women make me feel sick to this day. Like the opening scenes in "Leaving Las Vegas," there are some images that I cannot get out of my head, that terrify me in the dark of sleepless nights. Why our culture embraces tales of depravity, I'll never understand. But letting 13 or 14 year old be exposed to such is criminal.
Adult books are not for kids. Even adults shouldn't be reading most of them.
Now for the boring stuff about finding age appropriate reading material for your children.
Our local library uses the Dewey Decimal System, as do most public libraries. Like it or not, the DDS leaves a lot of ambiguity with the generic "F" for Fiction. In Youth Services, the vague delineations are furthered with "JF" for Juvenile Fiction and "YF" for Young Adult Fiction. The hard-working people who decide whether a book is J or Y, most likely use reading level, and in special cases, content. Juvenile fiction is generally for elementary school children, up to about 6th grade. Young Adult is then for the middle school kids, 7th and 8th grades. Some libraries have a High School section, which includes adult books about teenagers, or content judged inappropriate for children.
There is a lot of crossover between J and Y books, and each library makes it's own calls. You may find the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series in either category, depending on which library you go to. In Juvenile books, you can find all the silly, gross, My Butt from Mars type books. But, (no pun intended) you can also find nearly every children's classic and loads of good stories that will interest readers of any age. In Young Adult, you can find most of the paranormal (Cirque du Freak, Twilight, etc.), romances (from Princess Diaries to Anne of Avonlea), and weightier themes such as crime, death of a loved one, homelessness, etc.
Young Adult books are some of the greatest books I've ever read. And also some of the worst. I believe that writing for this age group is often more demanding than writing for children or adults. I also realize that the popularity machine that catapults books into a frenzied craze begins with young adults. So, when reading YA, I am always cautious, and often amazed with what I find.
Here is a list of several YA books that I read, enjoyed, and consider appropriate for my teen son and daughter.
The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman
Schooled by Gordon Korman
The Dangerous Days of Daniel X by James Patterson
Trouble by Gary D. Schmidt
Peak by Roland Smith
When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead
Leviathan by Scot Westerfeld
Vampire Rising by Jason Henderson
Stormbreaker by Anthony Horowitz
Woods Runner by Gary Paulsen
Notes from the Midnight Driver by Jordan Sonnenblick
Little Blog on the Prairie by Cathleen Davitt Bell
Princess of the Midnight Ball by Jessica Day George
3 comments:
Can a 7th grader read any of these? We're going on vacation and I need to get her some books.
ReplyDelete
kathyHi I am in 8th grade and find that most of the books my mother suggests are boring. So I have come up with a list of books that are not all about sex and despair and they are deemed appropriate for 7th and 8th graders. Enjoy!
ReplyDelete
1. Beastly- by Alex Finn: a classic romance novel about Beauty and the Beast retold in a modern teenage setting. There are mild curse words.
2. The Lost Hero- by Rick Riordan: Sorta of a sequel to The Lighting Thief but with different characters.
3. Rules-by Cynthia Lord: I enjoyed this book very much. It is about a young girl dealing with a brother who has a disability. You see the characters grow in this story.
4. Matched-by Ally Condle: This book was ok. Similar to the Hunger Games but without all the deaths. It had a good story but it was a little hard to follow.
5. Small Steps- by Louis Sachar: I loved this book. A sequel to Holes though you don't have to read it to understand this book. A story about a boy putting his life together and finding people in his life that truly matter.
6. A Drowned Maiden's Hair-by Laura Schlitz: This is my favorite book besides Harry Potter. It is age appropriate for younger children as well.
7. Wish-by Alexandra Bullen: This book is very fun to read. A girl gets three dresses (three wishes) and finds some surprises along the way. I wouldn't recommend it for 6th and 7th because it has the brief mentioning of gays, drinking, and some slight cursing.
Sorry if theses books are a little girly.Thanks Young Critic! I have read lots on your list and then some. LOVED Matched by Ally Condie. I had forgotten about that one. I just finished I Am Number Four and enjoyed that one too.
ReplyDelete
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Can a 7th grader read any of these? We're going on vacation and I need to get her some books.
ReplyDeletekathy
Hi I am in 8th grade and find that most of the books my mother suggests are boring. So I have come up with a list of books that are not all about sex and despair and they are deemed appropriate for 7th and 8th graders. Enjoy!
ReplyDelete1. Beastly- by Alex Finn: a classic romance novel about Beauty and the Beast retold in a modern teenage setting. There are mild curse words.
2. The Lost Hero- by Rick Riordan: Sorta of a sequel to The Lighting Thief but with different characters.
3. Rules-by Cynthia Lord: I enjoyed this book very much. It is about a young girl dealing with a brother who has a disability. You see the characters grow in this story.
4. Matched-by Ally Condle: This book was ok. Similar to the Hunger Games but without all the deaths. It had a good story but it was a little hard to follow.
5. Small Steps- by Louis Sachar: I loved this book. A sequel to Holes though you don't have to read it to understand this book. A story about a boy putting his life together and finding people in his life that truly matter.
6. A Drowned Maiden's Hair-by Laura Schlitz: This is my favorite book besides Harry Potter. It is age appropriate for younger children as well.
7. Wish-by Alexandra Bullen: This book is very fun to read. A girl gets three dresses (three wishes) and finds some surprises along the way. I wouldn't recommend it for 6th and 7th because it has the brief mentioning of gays, drinking, and some slight cursing.
Sorry if theses books are a little girly.
Thanks Young Critic! I have read lots on your list and then some. LOVED Matched by Ally Condie. I had forgotten about that one. I just finished I Am Number Four and enjoyed that one too.
ReplyDelete