Wednesday, January 8, 2014

WWRW: in which Hell has frozen over

Me?  Reviewing non-fiction?  Reviewing books that I haven't even completely read?  Perhaps during the Polar Vortex we are emerging from, Hell has frozen over.



On New Year's Eve, a dear and trusted friend told me about Malcolm Gladwell's new book,David and Goliath: Underdogs, Misfits, and the Art of Battling Giants.


Specifically, she was telling me about the chapter on dyslexia.  Something like 30% of all successful entrepreneurs are dyslexic.   The chapter is named David Boies:  You wouldn't wish dyslexia on your child, or would you?

I read that chapter, and it was nice little summary/intro to the much more scientifically researched book that I am entrenched in called The Dyslexic Advantage: Unlocking the Hidden Potential of the Dyslexic Brain by Brock and Fernette Eide.


The theory behind The Dyslexia Advantage is that the dyslexic brain works so differently from the non-dyslexic brain, yet excels in very specific areas that the non-dyslexic brain struggles with, perhaps dyslexia is more of an "other-ability" rather than a disability.  That's my rudimentary layman's translation of the idea behind a book that I am only 33% finished with.

Though I am reading it very slowly, sometimes mumbling phrases out loud over and over again before my fiction-soaked brain can absorb the meaning, I am quite astonished at the number and variety of highly successful people who have dyslexia including the inventor of the cd player, Einstein, and Leonardo da Vinci.
For example, one featured individual, Jack, states, "I still can't spell and I still don't know my multiplication tables, and I've never read a book cover to cover without books on tape, but hey-it's okay!  I'm doing just fine."

The authors continue, "Just fine for Jack includes a bachelor's degree in conservation and resource studies from the University of California-Berkeley, a master's in wildlife biology from the University of Montana, and a degree in scientific illustration from the University of California-Santa Cruz."

The Dyslexia Advantage is giving me great insight into the way Edmund's mind works.  Some chapters and talents don't really seem to apply to my son.  For example, unlike many dyslexics, Edmund does not really care for Legos and never has.

But these statements lay out some of his struggles with conventional schooling perfectly:
A classic example is the multiple-choice exam.  Cynics might be forgiven for suspecting that multiple-choice exams-with their terse, dense, noncontextual sentences-were designed specifically to trip up individuals with dyslexia who excel in detecting secondary meanings or distant word relationships.  These examinees will often pore over a multiple-choice exam like a lawyer vetting a contract, finding loopholes, ambiguities, and potential exceptions where none are intended.  While their classmates evaluate questions with a "reasonable doubt" standard, they search for "proof beyond a shadow of a doubt."   As a result, even a hint of uncertainty leads them to reject answers that most students would identify as correct.  If their reading is also somewhat dodgy, the multiple-choice exam usually becomes a nightmare.  But even dyslexic students who read longer passages or whole books with excellent comprehension may struggle with multiple-choice exams.
Even at St. Jude's School for Kids Who Want to Read Good and Do Other Things Good Too, Edmund struggles with his online audio Faith and Life religion tests, precisely because they are multiple-choice.  Patrick and I have gone over his wrong answers, and the reasons he gives for not choosing the correct answer often involve that it was not correct enough, or that the answer he chose was correct and more open-ended.

So, that's the tome I'm wrestling with these days.  Let's hear what you've been reading:

7 comments:

  1. Yay! WWRW! I've got a great book to review, as soon as I feed these gremlins. Oh, and I'm going to pass these recs along to one of my best friends who is struggling with homeschooling her dyslexic child right now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I can't wait to read that second one. And I always forget F&L has online options!

    ReplyDelete
  3. So glad you're back! I need to check out those books--been wondering about one of my sons and dyslexia.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm going to look into these for mine with dyslexia. My son does have skills I couldn't dream of obtaining all the while forgetting to ever capitalize a letter or use end punctuation. I'm dreading standardized tests for him, but know I don't worry about his success in real life. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm going to do a WWRW post--but I'm going to be late!

    Interesting stuff about dyslexia. My husband's sister is pretty sure she has it, but when she was in school it really wasn't something they diagnosed. She never got super high grades, but she is uber intelligent and has a great mind for business.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No worries, Laura. The link-up is live until next Tuesday.

      Delete
  6. Just put a hold on the new Malcolm Gladwell book (okay, the audio discs) - I've really enjoyed Outliers, Blink and Tipping Point.

    Many of my family members have some degree of dyslexia. My dad managed to get a doctorate despite it and is retired from an administrative position at a local college and is currently a partner in a performance consulting firm.

    Can't wait to listen to his latest book :)

    ReplyDelete

Wednesday, January 8, 2014

WWRW: in which Hell has frozen over

Me?  Reviewing non-fiction?  Reviewing books that I haven't even completely read?  Perhaps during the Polar Vortex we are emerging from, Hell has frozen over.



On New Year's Eve, a dear and trusted friend told me about Malcolm Gladwell's new book,David and Goliath: Underdogs, Misfits, and the Art of Battling Giants.


Specifically, she was telling me about the chapter on dyslexia.  Something like 30% of all successful entrepreneurs are dyslexic.   The chapter is named David Boies:  You wouldn't wish dyslexia on your child, or would you?

I read that chapter, and it was nice little summary/intro to the much more scientifically researched book that I am entrenched in called The Dyslexic Advantage: Unlocking the Hidden Potential of the Dyslexic Brain by Brock and Fernette Eide.


The theory behind The Dyslexia Advantage is that the dyslexic brain works so differently from the non-dyslexic brain, yet excels in very specific areas that the non-dyslexic brain struggles with, perhaps dyslexia is more of an "other-ability" rather than a disability.  That's my rudimentary layman's translation of the idea behind a book that I am only 33% finished with.

Though I am reading it very slowly, sometimes mumbling phrases out loud over and over again before my fiction-soaked brain can absorb the meaning, I am quite astonished at the number and variety of highly successful people who have dyslexia including the inventor of the cd player, Einstein, and Leonardo da Vinci.
For example, one featured individual, Jack, states, "I still can't spell and I still don't know my multiplication tables, and I've never read a book cover to cover without books on tape, but hey-it's okay!  I'm doing just fine."

The authors continue, "Just fine for Jack includes a bachelor's degree in conservation and resource studies from the University of California-Berkeley, a master's in wildlife biology from the University of Montana, and a degree in scientific illustration from the University of California-Santa Cruz."

The Dyslexia Advantage is giving me great insight into the way Edmund's mind works.  Some chapters and talents don't really seem to apply to my son.  For example, unlike many dyslexics, Edmund does not really care for Legos and never has.

But these statements lay out some of his struggles with conventional schooling perfectly:
A classic example is the multiple-choice exam.  Cynics might be forgiven for suspecting that multiple-choice exams-with their terse, dense, noncontextual sentences-were designed specifically to trip up individuals with dyslexia who excel in detecting secondary meanings or distant word relationships.  These examinees will often pore over a multiple-choice exam like a lawyer vetting a contract, finding loopholes, ambiguities, and potential exceptions where none are intended.  While their classmates evaluate questions with a "reasonable doubt" standard, they search for "proof beyond a shadow of a doubt."   As a result, even a hint of uncertainty leads them to reject answers that most students would identify as correct.  If their reading is also somewhat dodgy, the multiple-choice exam usually becomes a nightmare.  But even dyslexic students who read longer passages or whole books with excellent comprehension may struggle with multiple-choice exams.
Even at St. Jude's School for Kids Who Want to Read Good and Do Other Things Good Too, Edmund struggles with his online audio Faith and Life religion tests, precisely because they are multiple-choice.  Patrick and I have gone over his wrong answers, and the reasons he gives for not choosing the correct answer often involve that it was not correct enough, or that the answer he chose was correct and more open-ended.

So, that's the tome I'm wrestling with these days.  Let's hear what you've been reading:

7 comments:

  1. Yay! WWRW! I've got a great book to review, as soon as I feed these gremlins. Oh, and I'm going to pass these recs along to one of my best friends who is struggling with homeschooling her dyslexic child right now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I can't wait to read that second one. And I always forget F&L has online options!

    ReplyDelete
  3. So glad you're back! I need to check out those books--been wondering about one of my sons and dyslexia.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm going to look into these for mine with dyslexia. My son does have skills I couldn't dream of obtaining all the while forgetting to ever capitalize a letter or use end punctuation. I'm dreading standardized tests for him, but know I don't worry about his success in real life. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm going to do a WWRW post--but I'm going to be late!

    Interesting stuff about dyslexia. My husband's sister is pretty sure she has it, but when she was in school it really wasn't something they diagnosed. She never got super high grades, but she is uber intelligent and has a great mind for business.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No worries, Laura. The link-up is live until next Tuesday.

      Delete
  6. Just put a hold on the new Malcolm Gladwell book (okay, the audio discs) - I've really enjoyed Outliers, Blink and Tipping Point.

    Many of my family members have some degree of dyslexia. My dad managed to get a doctorate despite it and is retired from an administrative position at a local college and is currently a partner in a performance consulting firm.

    Can't wait to listen to his latest book :)

    ReplyDelete